Skip to main content

The Answers Depend on the Questions You Ask

The answers depend on the questions you ask. What a simple and provocative statement! When we worry about students who don't seem to be making progress we often start by asking questions such as these:

--Why can't F. retell simple stories?
--Why does F. get a blank look on her face when you ask her a simple question?
--Why does F. sometimes seem to know what's going on and at other times, she hasn't a clue?

I could go one and on in this same vein but I don't think it's necessary since you may have already noticed that all these questions are phrased negatively - what D. can't do. They all operate from weaknesses and deficits. The answers will only lead me to more cant's and probably even some "wont's".

If, on the other hand, I explore what D. can do, and what her interests seem to be I might be able to use her strengths and interests to help her improve her ability to listen and attend so that she can learn more and better. I noticed that F. likes to draw. Often, though, her drawings are simple and feminine in nature. How can I start with something she's already doing and enjoys to get F. to think, write, and read on a deeper level?

Comments

Anonymous said…
I am very happy to have found your blog,Elisa! I enjoyed reading your "ruminations" and I happen to agree that negatively phrased questions will lead to more can'ts/won'ts and that looking for can dos is a wonderful way to find an answer.
Cindy
Unknown said…
Hi Cindy,
Glad that you found me. :) Now, that I've made my blog public (it took a while to work up the courage!) and that people are beginning to respond, I feel more confident about continuing the conversation. Hope to read your comments again, soon!
Elisa
Anonymous said…
Hi Elisa!
It took me a while to work up the courage to make my first blog public too! It was really scary for me to put my thoughts/ideas out in such a public forum. I thought I would sound stupid. I think your blog makes for excellent reading and much reflection - a critical part of being a good teacher I think. Keep on blogging!
Cindy
Unknown said…
Thank you, Cindy! It's comments like yours that help me want to keep blogging. I'm actually enjoying posting and it helps me reflect about what's going on in the classroom. Although I have a professional journal as well, it's nice to post public comments that others can respond to. Do you blog?
Elisa

Popular posts from this blog

The Reading Strategies Book - Chapter 12, Supporting Students’ Conversations – Speaking, Listening, and Deepening Comprehension

The strategy lessons highlighted in Chapter 12, Supporting Students’ Conversations – Speaking, Listening, and Deepening Comprehension, in The Reading Strategies Book by Jennifer Serravallo are critical to students’ engagement and comprehension, as well as their ability to write literary essays, or even book reviews, summaries and reflective pieces about books. If students aren’t able to talk about books in a way that is invigorating and joyful, they will be less likely to develop an interest in growing ideas for writing about books. In her introduction to this chapter, Jennifer Serravallo, reminds us that when conversations go well, children are inspired by what they read and are motivated to keep reading. However, when conversations fall flat, then kids get bored and tune out. How do we avoid this situation and teach kids to  have  focused conversations about books?  The answer is easy: teach kids  strategies to help them develop effective conversa...

Partner Reading and Content, Too Routine (PRC2)

I'm a hoarder. There, I've said it. I try to deny that I'm a hoarder but it comes back to haunt me every time I move houses, or pack up my classroom at the end of the school year. I have old articles, lesson plans, handouts, folders brimming with teaching ideas, past issues of profesional journals. I hardly throw anything out though I've learned to be more selective over the years. My one rule of thumb, and I really try to stick to this, is that if I haven't used or referred to something in a year, then it's time to toss it into the recycle bin. One exception to this rule (you knew this was coming, didn't you?) is past issues of journals from professional organizations. However, with the ability to locate articles online through my professional memberships, even this exception is becoming less and less useful, which brings me to the topic of this blog post. I am currently reading a copy of The Reading Teacher from 2010. I've clipped a cou...

Rewards and Punishments

I'm always surprised and disappointed when educators I respect support the use of rewards and punishments to control student behaviour. Whenever I feel like my students are "misbehaving" or not behaving as expected or agreed, it's usually because I'm "misbehaving" or not behaving as expected or agreed. Sound odd? Perhaps, but think about this for a minute. When something goes wrong, i.e. not according to plan, it's usually because the kids have responded in unexpected ways to what I'm teaching or presenting to them. Unless I'm prepared to handle these contingencies I can lose focus of the lesson and the children. I find that the best way to deal with these "disruptions" isn't to control behaviour through carrots and sticks but rather to take a deep breath and think about what may be causing the problem. Often the cause has to do with one or more of the following: how I've presented the lesson (it's confusing, ...